Testing AI Models

Image Source

Artificial intelligence (AI) is a broad field of computer science that seeks to create intelligent machines that can perform tasks that typically require human intelligence. AI research has been highly successful in developing effective techniques for solving a wide range of problems.

AI model is a tool or algorithm which is based on a certain data set through which it can arrive at a decision — all without the need for human interference in the decision-making process. It is a program that analyzes datasets to find patterns and make predictions on that basis, which allows it to recognize patterns. AI models are particularly suitable for solving complex problems.

Common examples of AI models include Virtual assistants, like Siri, Facial recognition, Text Generating Language models, like Chat GPT, and Image Generating models: text to image and image to image.

Testing AI models is important for a number of reasons, such as:

• Ensuring Accuracy and Reliability
• Preventing Bias and Discrimination
• Maintaining Robustness and Security
• Building Trust and Transparency
• Promoting Responsible AI Development

There are several challenges to testing AI models. These can include:

• Black-box nature: Many AI models, especially deep neural networks, are complex and opaque, making it difficult to understand how they arrive at their decisions. This can make it challenging to identify the root cause of errors.
• Data dependence: The performance of an AI model is heavily dependent on the quality and quantity of the data used for training. Testing must consider potential biases and limitations in the data to ensure generalisability.
• Evolving nature: AI is a rapidly evolving field, with new algorithms and techniques emerging constantly. Testing methodologies need to be adaptable and flexible to keep pace with these advancements.

In testing AI models, there are several roles that can be incorporated to ensure that the quality is maintained since different roles bring in different levels of knowledge to the different layers on which the AI model is built. As a team, it is important to include the efforts and context of all such roles that can ensure the quality. AI, Data, and QA engineers collaborate to test AI models in the following ways:

AI Engineers:

• Model Design and Training: They provide deep understanding of the LLM architecture, training data, and potential biases. This guides test case design and helps interpret test results.
• Explainability and Fairness: They implement tools for understanding the LLM’s reasoning and identifying potential bias. This helps QA engineers assess the model’s fairness and robustness.
• Metrics and Evaluation: They define relevant metrics for evaluating the LLM’s performance on different tasks (e.g., accuracy, fluency, factual correctness). This sets clear benchmarks for QA testing.

Data Engineers:

• Data Acquisition and Management: They ensure access to diverse, high-quality datasets for testing. This helps identify edge cases and ensure the LLM generalizes well.
• Data Annotation and Labeling: They develop efficient pipelines for annotating and labeling test data, considering different language contexts and nuances. This ensures accurate evaluation of the LLM’s performance.
• Scalability and Infrastructure: They provide the necessary infrastructure and tools for handling large-scale LLM testing, including distributed computing and data storage solutions. This allows for efficient and comprehensive testing.

QA Engineers’ role in testing AI models includes but is not limited o:

• Understanding AI models. Gain a deep understanding of the AI model’s intended purpose, its algorithms, and the data it uses.
• Designing test scenarios. Develop test scenarios that simulate real-world situations, including challenging and unexpected cases.
• Testing performance. Assess the model’s performance in terms of accuracy and speed.
• Evaluating for bias and fairness. Check for bias in AI decisions and ensure fairness in outcomes across demographic groups.
• Providing documentation. Maintain comprehensive records of testing procedures, test results, and issues.

Additionally, QA engineers can utilize their existing knowledge to map software testing types to Machine Learning models to verify the behaviour. An approach that can be followed is to perform:

• Unit test. Check the correctness of individual model components.
• Regression test. Check whether your model breaks and test for previously encountered bugs.
• Integration test. Check whether the different components work with each other within your machine learning pipeline.

We can run post train tests on a LLM by asking some questions, and analyzing the answers it generates, and compare them with the expected outcomes based on characters. Based on this data, we can use some parameters to assess the correctness of the model. Testing image-based AI models involves evaluating the model’s performance in understanding and making predictions based on visual data. An image model can generate image based on input text data. There are some parameters on which AI models can be tested. Many of these are deduced from academic research papers.

• Match Function: The match function determines the similarity or agreement between the predicted output and the actual (ground truth) output. It returns 1 for a match and 0 for a mismatch.
• Error Rate: It counts when there are errors or mismatches. It returns 0 for a match and 1 for a mismatch.
• Overall Accuracy: Overall accuracy represents the proportion of correct predictions over the total number of predictions. It provides a general measure of how well the model is performing. It sums the match count 1’s so far and takes average based on total number of cases. So, Sum(matches)/Count(matches)
• Overall Error Rate: The overall error rate is the complement of overall accuracy, indicating the proportion of incorrect predictions over the total number of predictions. It sums the error count 1’s so far and takes average based on total number of cases. So, Sum(errors)/Count(errors). Since Match function and Error rate are mutually exclusive, it is also calculated by 1 — Overall Accuracy
• Precision: Precision is the ratio of true positive predictions to the total number of positive predictions made by the model. It measures the accuracy of the positive predictions made by the model. It is returning the same value as overall accuracy but the formula is slightly different.
• Recall: Recall, also known as sensitivity or true positive rate, is the ratio of true positive predictions to the total number of actual positives. It is measured using overall accuracy and precision.
• F1 Score: The F1 score is the mean of precision and recall. It provides a balanced measure that considers both false positives and false negatives.
• Confusion Matrix: A confusion matrix is a table that presents a summary of the model’s performance. It includes values such as true positives (TP), true negatives (TN), false positives (FP), and false negatives (FN).
• True Negative (TN): The number of instances that were correctly predicted as negative by the model.
• True Positive (TP): The number of instances that were correctly predicted as positive by the model.
• False Positive (FP): The number of instances that were predicted as positive by the model but are actually negative.
• False Negative (FN): The number of instances that were predicted as negative by the model but are actually positive.
• BLEU: BLEU (Bilingual Evaluation Understudy) is a metric commonly used for evaluating the quality of machine-generated text, such as translations. It compares the output text to one or more reference texts.
• Calculate Precision for 1-Grams: In the context of text generation or translation tasks, this involves calculating the precision specifically for unigrams (single words) in the generated text. Precision for 1-grams measures the accuracy of individual words in the generated output.

These are some of the parameters that can be utilised in accessing the accuracy and reliability of AI Models. Quality Assurance Engineers have a range of tools at hand that they are familiar with, when it comes to test automation, performance testing, security testing, etc. Similarly, they can leverage that experience to extend their skills to conduct testing in the domain of AI also.